Cbass limits bust!!

[SaltLife1980]

Originally Posted by Harpoon

So on a 6 pack charter if the captain and mate allow you to keep their fish does that make you a poacher or a pirate? I'd love to hear from SaltLife on this one too.

If you have your limit how many more fish do you need.. I will give my fish away to the people that did not catch there limit.. i dont want people to walk off the boat with over there limit and get in trouble.. But the guy that was 2 short of a limit of course i will give him 2 fish to make his limit..

Fishing for a guy that is sick is way different then keeping over your limit.. Jay picked up some extra fish for people who are green in the cabin.. That was the nice thing to do..

[aduma1107]

Originally Posted by SaltLife1980

If you have your limit how many more fish do you need.. I will give my fish away to the people that did not catch there limit.. i dont want people to walk off the boat with over there limit and get in trouble.. But the guy that was 2 short of a limit of course i will give him 2 fish to make his limit..

Fishing for a guy that is sick is way different then keeping over your limit.. Jay picked up some extra fish for people who are green in the cabin.. That was the nice thing to do..

Second that. Boat limit...if the boat get it's limit for 32 fares then all is good. Even for the greenies

[Harpoon]

Originally Posted by SaltLife1980

If you have your limit how many more fish do you need.. I will give my fish away to the people that did not catch there limit.. i dont want people to walk off the boat with over there limit and get in trouble.. But the guy that was 2 short of a limit of course i will give him 2 fish to make his limit..

Fishing for a guy that is sick is way different then keeping over your limit.. Jay picked up some extra fish for people who are green in the cabin.. That was the nice thing to do..

I was asking cause Gotcha thinks Jay poached, which I would not categorize what he did as poaching. I know since you are a mate that you would have an opinion about what happens on Papa's Angles or other boats that you work on when fares catch captains/mates share of the catch. Me I don't believe it is poaching...but just wanted to hear from someone that works on the boats.

Also when F/G count each individual anglers catch do they take into account the fish that could have come from the crews #'s? For argument sake we will say there are 10 fares on the boat and 2 mates and a captain. Boat limit to me would be 10 fares x 15 cbass per fare plus 15 cbass a piece for each mate and the captain. Just like on a 6pack charter during fluke season. A lot of charters will allow the fares to keep the captains and mates share of the fluke. Does this thinking go into effect when they are writing tickets? I'm not being a smart ass either this is a serious question.

[GOTCHA1224]

Originally Posted by Harpoon

I was asking cause Gotcha thinks Jay poached, which I would not categorize what he did as poaching. I know since you are a mate that you would have an opinion about what happens on Papa's Angles or other boats that you work on when fares catch captains/mates share of the catch. Me I don't believe it is poaching...but just wanted to hear from someone that works on the boats.

Also when F/G count each individual anglers catch do they take into account the fish that could have come from the crews #'s? For argument sake we will say there are 10 fares on the boat and 2 mates and a captain. Boat limit to me would be 10 fares x 15 cbass per fare plus 15 cbass a piece for each mate and the captain. Just like on a 6pack charter during fluke season. A lot of charters will allow the fares to keep the captains and mates share of the fluke. Does this thinking go into effect when they are writing tickets? I'm not being a smart ass either this is a serious question.

do the math you charter a boat keep 5 fluke each whole plus the captain and mate's fish that would be 40 fluke. you load the fish in the truck drive away and get stopped by fish and game ,they search the cooler and find 40 whole fluke and only 6 guys in thetruck.guess what you are getting fined for ten fluke over your limit.

[Harpoon]

Originally Posted by GOTCHA1224

do the math you charter a boat keep 5 fluke each whole plus the captain and mate's fish that would be 40 fluke. you load the fish in the truck drive away and get stopped by fish and game ,they search the cooler and find 40 whole fluke and only 6 guys in thetruck.guess what you are getting fined for ten fluke over your limit.

Huh? No dude I gotta say you got that wrong. Take a charter and you are allowed to keep the mates and captains catch. I don't think you have a leg (even a peg leg) to stand on in this situation!

[GOTCHA1224]

you are dead wrong bet me a grand or a better bet if im wrong i will buy you a charter trip on the monger if you are wrong you buy me a trip on the monger.but officer these extra ten fluke belong to the captain and mate.

[Harpoon]

Originally Posted by GOTCHA1224

you are dead wrong bet me a grand or a better bet if im wrong i will buy you a charter trip on the monger if you are wrong you buy me a trip on the monger.but officer these extra ten fluke belong to the captain and mate.

Nah...I don't belong to Monger nation. Thanks anyway!

[Fishguts]

Originally Posted by Harpoon

Nah...I don't belong to Monger nation. Thanks anyway!

So is the law a catch limit and not possession limit?????? Are you only allowed to catch a limit..... are you only allowed to keep a limit ......or are you only allowed to be in possession of a limit when stopped returning from a fishing trip? Was the person stopped on the water or in their vehicle. Guys betting a grand must be very sure of himself . Hmmmmmmmmmm but how can one really come to a true conclusion of who is correct. Maybe a call to Fish and Game. Better yet how about the deciding factor will be a photo copy of a summons of what an individual is charged with or better still how about a copy of the court summons and a paid receipt of the fine.
Yep looks like there will be one winner and one thousand dollar loser.

[sportfishingusa]

I didnt know so many grown adults can wear womens panties.. geez batman, did everyone turn their thongs around backwards hoping for more snow?

i would rather watch a rodent look for his shadow, they got fined, they got caught, who cares who is right and who is wrong.. i kill my limit as often as i can, and guess what? i dont even take them home to cook...

[Ol Pedro]

Originally Posted by Harpoon

Huh? No dude I gotta say you got that wrong. Take a charter and you are allowed to keep the mates and captains catch. I don't think you have a leg (even a peg leg) to stand on in this situation!

If I have my 15 Bass filleted with skin attached that is my posession limit . I can't take extra fish home . Each angler should only have his possession limit . Who cares who caught them as long as they are what that person can possess legally when they step off the boat . If it said 15 @12.5" 15 in posession then you can only have 15 . If I'm wrong please correct me .