Islamorada, Marathon or Key West ?

[Skolmann]

As a birthday gift my wife and kids are giving me a trip to the Keys for 5 days (April 1-5) of fishing. Having a hard time deciding between Islamorada, Marathon or Key West. I've been to the Keys many times but it's been several years since my last visit.

I'd like to do 1 day offshore, 1 day reef/wreck fishing and the 3rd day either tarpon, shark or backcountry fishing. Might even try and get in a night party boat trip or perhaps do a night tarpon trip.

Decisions, decisions

What/where would you go ?

PS: I'm kinda leaning (ever so slightly) to Key West