Wild Brookie in an urban creek?

[njmultispecies]

So I have been exploring local ponds, rivers, and streams. So I fished this creek that runs through my town. Threw a trout magnet with no luck or a while. Then, I found some holes with a very healthy population of pumkinseeds and creek chubs. (Some of these creek chubs were above the 7 in mark.) Then I spotted something bigger dart upstream. I thought nothing of it at first, making a cast toward that general area convincing myself it was just another chub and kept fishing. Then I saw it again, this time stopping near me, within eyes view. It was a brookie, a nice one too. Nearly fainted, considering the patterns on the fish and the fact that I was fishing next to a gas station. Casted my trout magnet past him, tried to get a bite and spooked him. Fished for another 30 mins there with no trout. Came back later to fish but didn't see it. Is it possible that there are wild reproducing trout in this creek? Keep in mind it runs past a bunch of stores and businesses and is full of trash Or do you think it was a leftover stockie? Just a little report/story and tight lines.

[Chrisper4694]

well my first thought is, you're mistaking it for something else, and the water was playing tricks on your eyes, but hey you never know! could've been from a club stocking or something. the state didn't stock any brookies for the past few years so if its a stocker it's been holding over for a while.

only way to find out for sure is to catch it! looking forward to seeing a pic!

[Adrenalinerush]

You can answer your question by asking yourself a few. Forget where the stream is and consider the following:
Does it have good water flow year round?
Does the temperature get much above 72 degrees in the summer or is it possibly spring fed in the area you saw the fish?
Despite the urban setting and the fact that it is "full of trash" is the water dirty of generally clear and clean?
Does it run into a larger stream or river that hold brook trout or one that has been stocked with brook trout in the past?

[Mark B.]

In the mid 1980’s, @ the urging of the now defunct Toms River Trout Unlimited Chapter, NJDF&W back pack electrofished Toms River in Jackson. The anglers were sure that they observed juvenile, naturally reproduced Brook Trout. Though, they never caught any.

What they were seeing, which we collected, were Eastern Mudminnows. Through the water, they can look trout-like.

They can tolerate low dissolved oxygen & acidic water.

[briansnat]

It's possible. I know people who have caught wild browns on the Pequannock where it runs through the center of Bloomingdale behind gas stations, laundromats and nail salons.

[NJ Dave]

Originally Posted by briansnat

It's possible. I know people who have caught wild browns on the Pequannock where it runs through the center of Bloomingdale behind gas stations, laundromats and nail salons.

Ditto on that. Have caught plenty of true wild fish in that river. Small fish that fight well.
C & R on all of those

[Chrisper4694]

Originally Posted by Mark B.

In the mid 1980’s, @ the urging of the now defunct Toms River Trout Unlimited Chapter, NJDF&W back pack electrofished Toms River in Jackson. The anglers were sure that they observed juvenile, naturally reproduced Brook Trout. Though, they never caught any.

What they were seeing, which we collected, were Eastern Mudminnows. Through the water, they can look trout-like.

They can tolerate low dissolved oxygen & acidic water.

i'm going with this^

[njmultispecies]

Originally Posted by Mark B.

In the mid 1980’s, @ the urging of the now defunct Toms River Trout Unlimited Chapter, NJDF&W back pack electrofished Toms River in Jackson. The anglers were sure that they observed juvenile, naturally reproduced Brook Trout. Though, they never caught any.

What they were seeing, which we collected, were Eastern Mudminnows. Through the water, they can look trout-like.

They can tolerate low dissolved oxygen & acidic water.

The fish I saw had a red-ish fin and underbelly. It looked nothing like that.

[Jigman13]

Like this?

Chub...

[Ken Lyons]

I had a discussion years ago about that river with a guy from Fisheries. He was very high on it for trout. He said low water conditions are really better because of how much of the flow comes from springs.