Manasquan River Trout - Not!

[Cuz]

Met my son Doug at the Manasquan River in Howell this afternoon. What a sorry ass place to trout fish or even stock trout for that matter. It reminds me of the mudhole Passaic River off of Rte 78 and King George Rd. Warren, N.J. (They stopped stocking there years ago.) No rocks, stones, of gravel bottom. I can't fathom how a trout could possibly survive in this mudhole stream.
I slipped and fell down a muddy bank but luckily not into the water. Walk the river a ways and found most of it inaccessable due to years of growth. I caught a dozen bluegills and some chubs. Got back to my vehicle at last light, took my muddy cloths off and drove him in my underwear! Can't wait to get back to the South Branch and Pequest.
It's always great fishing with my son. But he has to give up this river and fish some real productive trout waters this state has to offer. And there are plenty.

[Wilson]

Mudhole...AGREE

[surfrod]

They don't call it the muddy-squan for nothing!

It, along with the Shark "River" and Hockhockson Brook, are 3 distinctly NJ coastal streams and not true trout waters.

The Squan has it's places that are fun to fish but you always have to be prepared for mud, and wear lug bottom boots, never felts. I've slid down those banks many times and well, to fish it is to have to deal with mud, period.

As to accessibility, I don't know the area you fished, but a lot of that growth is from one season, not years. Realize that very few trout can hold over there in the summer, if any and especially this year. Thus there are long stretches of the river that see no activity after 1st week in June. I see this on the Hock all the time (though the town has actually put in a nice trail... perhaps the scouts helped, whatever, a lot better than it used to be)

But no argument about the much much better trout waters up nawth.

[Lard Almighty]

I'm in total agreement. Besides Hockhockson, the Manasquan is the closest trout-stocked water to where I live, and I refuse to fish it!

BTW surfrod, there is at least one hole on Hockhockson that holds trout year-round, believe it or not.

[surfrod]

Lard, I know the Hock has some holdover spots...one in particular

I used to live a mile from the old grist mill... no longer, but I'm up that way visiting from time to time

I JUST took the plunge on a 2011 fw license/trout stamp, believe it or not.

Plan on hitting the squan and toms, and perhaps the shark and hock just for kicks... though I understand they didn't get any surplus fingerlings this year.

[Jerseydix]

Tried that mud pit today, tossed and lost a few lures. Very muddy. Maybe the state should stock some Smallies in there?

[Mark B.]

Yes, the Muddysquan. I too, being used to north jersey mud, have taken a couple of good slides on it!! They are what they are,…..the few trout maintenance streams (cold enough to hold trout over the summer)in the area: ‘Squan, Mingamahone, Toms, North Branch Metedeconk. They ain’t no Ken Lockwood Gorge, but are good for resident anglers who don’t want to travel too far to catch trout year ‘round,…..maybe even an elusive searun in the ‘Squan (also gets all of the State’s surplus browns, in addition to the bit larger, “searun trainees”). Whenever the State has surplus rainbows & brooks, they go to the Hock. & Toms, respectively, as there have been reports of searuns of those species (steelheads & salters), there.

In addition to the ‘Squan’s slippery mud (must have some clay in it?), all have many snags and overgrown banks, making wading necessary to fish them. Many fly anglers use severely shortened blanks, and backcasts, to avoid getting hung up in the shoreline thicket. Very deep holes,…….especially on Toms.


Below is my response to an angler’s recent, age old question: “Went fishing on the day the State stocked it. Fished hard & didn’t get a nibble. Did the State really stock it?”



The trout just weren't biting that day.

The Manasquan River received 650 trout on 10/11/11. All stocking points were stocked.

One of our fisheries technicians was there that day, conducting an angler count. He counted 12 adult anglers, and 1 juvenile @ three of the more popular stocking points: Squankum Dam, Hospital Rd., and Brice Park. No trout were caught on a variety of lures & bait. However, two white suckers were caught on worms.

Those 12 anglers commented to the fish tech., that yeah,..........they saw the hatchery truck stock the trout (some nice ones!). They even saw some of the trout rising,....furthering their frustration.

So, you weren't alone!

Better luck fishing in the future,....I assure you,...they're out there!



Mark Boriek, Principal Fisheries Biologist
Mark.Boriek@earthlink.net

NJ Division of Fish & Wildlife
Bureau of Freshwater Fisheries
P.O. Box 394, 1255 County Rt. 629
Lebanon, NJ 08833

(908) 236-2118 Fax: (908) 236-7280

Visit our website at www.NJFishandWildlife.com <http://www.njfishandwildlife.com/>

[Wilson]

Well there you have it from the horses mouth. Nice post Mark. There are quite a few Trout guys on this board, and lots of them say "they didn't stock". Seems the fall Trout are a little smarter then the Spring ones. I'm guessing that the warmer water in the fall puts them off untill they get acclimated to the new water temps. Do you have any ideas on that thought?

[Mark B.]

Originally Posted by Wilson

Well there you have it from the horses mouth. Nice post Mark. There are quite a few Trout guys on this board, and lots of them say "they didn't stock". Seems the fall Trout are a little smarter then the Spring ones. I'm guessing that the warmer water in the fall puts them off untill they get acclimated to the new water temps. Do you have any ideas on that thought?

Could be the warmer water temp. That seemed to be the case last fall,....we were in a drought, & anglers were really complaining about not catching any, at first. In a couple of weeks,..it got colder, & they started catching. Today, the winds are still out of the southwest. When we get those colder northwest winds, they'll start biting.

In my above post, forgot to include Hockhockson as one of the area's trout maintenance streams.

[Jerseydix]

Thanks Mark. Good info. I'll keep trying the Squan, had better luck on the NB of the 'Conk.