If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Lures out of the numerous tackle boxes you have what are your top favorite?

What would be the single most important "go-to" lures that you would select IF YOU COULD ONLY PICK 5?

Five is a tough choice and I would like to pick 10, but if I had to pick 5

Here are mine:

1. Rooster tail (white)
2. Zoom Superfluke (white)
3. Lizard or worm fished Carolina style (prefer a lizard)
4. top water popper
5. Rattle trap or equiv.

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1-Zara spook
2- bullet weighted turtle back gulp in natural
3- white 1/32 oz. prop blade rooster tai
4-Power bait and a meal worm
5- cd7 rapala- black n silver

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1/32 oz jigs
Motor oil,plastic worm
Fin s
Rapala ice jig
rooster tail yellow

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Mepps spinner (white tail)
2. Jointed rapala
3. Gulp three inch grub
4. Dardevle
5. Zara spook

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. 3" curly tail grub, white
2. 5" Senko, pumpkinseed
3. #2 Mepps Aglia spinner, silver
4. Rebel Pop-R, silver/black
5. Rapala CD5, rainbow trout

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Husky jerk 14(black & silver)
2. Mepps giant killer
3. Yum senko worm baby bass color
4. Boo yah spinner bait
5. Mepps giants killer different color from the first

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Musky Baits

1)Soft-tailed Phantom-Natural Perch
2)Junior Double Cowgirl-Black/Orange
3)Jointed Reef Digger Soft-Tail-Northern Pike
4)Top Raider-Loon
5)Bull Dawg-Gitteroil/Orange

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Roostertail yellow
2. Dardevel 5 diamonds
3. Rapala silver
4. Black Marabou jig
5. Yellow Jitterbug

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Rapala original floating (silver)
2. 3/8 Jig head w/ tube (watermelon)
3. Spro frog (green)
4. Trout magnet (large)
5. Phoebe (gold)

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1)March Brown
2)Deer hair frog
3)Black Marabou Leech
4)Foam Beetle
5)Purple Crystal Bugger

Leif

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1.) Big Willow Bladed Spinnerbait

2.) Rapala Husky Jerk HJ-14

3.) Worden's Flatfish

4.) Jigging Rapala

5.) 4" Senko

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Rapala HJ-14 (Black/Silver)
2. Strike King Shim-e-Stick (Sweet Potato Pie)
3. Mepps Giant Killer (Firetiger)
4. Zoom Fat Albert Grub (Green Pumpkin)
5. Trout Magnet (Pink or Candy Corn)

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Panther Martin Black & Yellow #4
2. Panther Martin Black & Yellow #4
3. Panther Martin Black & Yellow #4
4. Panther Martin Black & Yellow #4
5. Panther Martin Black & Yellow #4

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Suspending Jerkbait
2. Chatterbait
3. Silver Buddy
4. Deps Basiriski frog
5. Koppers live target frog

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Interesting thread:

1. Willowblade spinner- white with silver blades
2. Trout magnet- pink or yellow
3. Senko- 4" pumpkin
4. Rooster tail rainbow pattern
5. Rapala jointed- firetiger

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1.) 1/4 oz snow white Booyah Tandem Blade spinnerbait
2.) 4" or 5" inch pumpkinseed Senko with green fleck
3.) Rapala Husky Jerk HJ14 Firetiger
4.) 2 1/4" Hula Popper, black
5.) Booyah Buzz Blade buzzbait 1/4 oz or 3/8 oz, black

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

I've attempted this list about 5 times today, I'm just gonna go with this.
In no particular order

- Strike King KVD perfect plastic caffeine shad -4" pearl color
- I'll jump on this Husky Jerk bandwagon, pick which ever one out of my box
- any chartreuse spinner bait with a hammered silver Colorado blade
- yellow 1/32 oz rooster tail with propeller blade
- Chartreuse lead head with a white Gulp Alive grub

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1) Yamamoto senko 5" black with blue fleck
2)Rapala original floater f11
3)Berkley Havoc pit boss lime/purple
4)Bill Lewis rat L trap 1/2 oz
5)Jitterbug original

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

cool post

different brands, colors, and sizes

1. 10" powerworm
2. frog with trailer hook
3. spoon
4. minnow
5. spinner

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1- 6" jointed "The Believer", by drifter tackle
2- red/black culprit twisty
3- Panther martin black/gold spinner
4- Large Zara Spook
5- Silver/Blue small acme Kastmaster spoon

*First post on Njfishing....really like the website

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1) 4" watermelon senko
2) 4" fin-s fish
3) white spinnerbait
4) black buzzbait
5) green or brown gitzit or any other tube

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Gosh, I started this thread thinking that my five where king of the hill. Lots of awesome suggestions that are both in and out of my current box leaving me to re-think the possibilities and needed investigations/presentations:cool:

Welcome: The Birdman to the Site and we are looking forward to all your future reports

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Large Shiners

Medium Shiners

Baby Night Crawlers

Herring

M-80 weighted. JK

Hellgramites

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. 5' Yamasenko Smoke Black Silver Flake
2. Terminator White Spinner Bait 3/8
3. Strike King Grass Frog 3/16
4. Bomber Fat Free Shad (fire Tiger)
5. Bomber Fat Free Shad Jr. (fire Tiger)

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

True story. If the zombie apocalypse started tomorrow Wilson actually carries all of the above on him at all times in case fishing for food becomes a necessity. :p

My 5:

2" Swimbait
2" Triple-Rippled tailed grub on a 1/16 oz jighead
6" Finesse/Trick Worm
Super Fluke
Brown Rooster Tail with a Copper Blade (1/16 or 1/8 oz depending on the body of water).

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Silver roostertail with white tail
2. trout magnet
3. #3 Mepps Aglia
4. CD 3 Rapala rainbow trout color
5. Rapala X-Rap 8

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1.) 3/8th or 1/4th size Chatterbait in Gill color
2.) 1/4 or 1/2 Crankbait in Chart or Red craw color
3.) Topwater popper or walking bait in shad color
4.) SHakeyhead worm
5.) Senko in smoked purple color

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Salmon egg pink

Herring

Worm

Meal worm

Rainbow rapala small

Guess Wilson and me are the bait fishermen.

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

Panther Martin - it really is the worlds greatest fish catcher. From pike to crappie to walleye to trout to bass to sunfish to pickerel to perch. It gets 'em all.

1/8 oz single blade buzzbait. It may not be the best fish catcher but nothing beats seeing a bass/pike or pickerel smash the hell out of it.

Surface popper. Best stillwater lure. Pretty much anything will grab it although removing 6 hooks from a pickerels mouth can be painful(for you not the fish).

1/8 oz spinnerbait double willow blade. Best cold/coolwater lure.

Zoom Horny Toad or any variation there of. Hookups are lousy but no denying bass love them.

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1) Flying Lure.
2)Banjo Minnow.
3)Helicopter Lure.
4)True Motion Lure.
5)Sonic Minnow.
All fished with my Pocket Fisherman.

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1.corn
2.nightcrawlers
3. homemade carp candy

no need for anything else

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1. Black Senko
2. White Spinnerbait
3. Lucky Craft Sammy
4. Strike King Red Eye Shad
5. Live Target Hollow Body Frog

Re: If You Could Only Pick Five
 

1) 7 inch PB Blue Fleck
2) Inline spinner (Like Mepps, Panther Martin)
3) White/Chartreuse 3/8 oz spinner
4) Bug & Bubble
5) Jig & Pig