Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

JOHN D- not really that important. I know we'll have at least 4, up to 6. One buddy will bring his wife, I'll bring my son (16), so a working head & a little room to stretch out are the real priorities, as far as type of boat. And an agressive captain who wants to catch fish, of course. :D

Thanks to all who responded, I think you've given me a lot to work with.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Just got the bad news that Captain Tom from Herls's Girl is taking a break this year from charter fishing, so I'm back on the lookout for a new charter captain in Montauk. Any suggestions? Have a regular crew of 6 guys that make the drive each year.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Wow. First I’ve heard this. I’ll call Tom and get a reference from him.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Probably the oldest Striper sharpest charter captain in Montauk. I wasn't aware that he was still in business but he's been in Montauk for over 60 years & been considered tops in the business for that long. That alone should tell you something.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

wee jack,capt scott wymbs.great capt,crew and boat.you will not be disappointed.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

FRANK MUNDUS hands down. Formerly out of Manasquan.

All you need is a séance and you will experience the true Captain Quint from Jaws.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

The keyword here is "IS"....:D

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Give Capt. Jamie of the Miss Montauk a call. His son just recently started his own charter business. He learned from one of the best. Boat is very nice and completely redone.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Viking Fivestar with Captain Steven Sr. Is better.

Re: Who is the BEST charter capain in Montauk?
 

Personal opinion plus capt Jamie is a sponsor! If party boat fishing the miss Montauk hands down.