Who is the tougher sportsman a fisherman or hunter?

[Kevin Bogan]

:confused: Hey Skip, I just saw an article on the internet that poses the question: Who is tougher, a Fisherman, or a Hunter"?
:cool: Oh yeah, I know the guy who wrote that. In fact he sent his research to me to have it fact checked, and he's right. After all, it was on the internet!;)
:D OK, aren't you going to tell me?
:cool: Well lets give the others a chance to join in. As acting commissioner of the "Council of Tough Sportsmen" I can only except answers that explain in a sentence or two as to why picked one or the other.
:D is the answer written in stone?????
:cool: No, the answer is written on the water!:;)

[Rocky]

That is a chicken and egg question in my opinion.

[bunker dunker]

never paid it much mind.just glad i'm both

[Capt. Debbie]

Kevin good point. But you miss the more important concern... that being who would win a fight Rocky or Rambo. LMAO

More fake news. Ask some clown his opinion and that is news?

:confused: Hey Skip, I just saw an article on the internet that poses the question: Who is tougher, a Fisherman, or a Hunter"?
:cool: Oh yeah, I know the guy who wrote that. In fact he sent his research to me to have it fact checked, and he's right. After all, it was on the internet!;)
:D OK, aren't you going to tell me?
:cool: Well lets give the others a chance to join in. As acting commissioner of the "Council of Tough Sportsmen" I can only except answers that explain in a sentence or two as to why picked one or the other.
:D is the answer written in stone?????
:cool: No, the answer is written on the water!:;)

[Rusty hook]

That is a tough choice, Why can't we have them both?!:D:D You ask me to pick either Scotch or beer, but I need both!:mad:

[Duffman]

Depends on what type of fishing and what type of hunting. Gotta compare apples to apples.

[Arbutis]

I have your solution for biggest bad-ass sportsman. . . the SpearFisherman wins, hands down.

Need proof? Give it a try.

[NoLimit]

I have a deer stand over a bass pond 😆

[Kevin Bogan]

I have your solution for biggest bad-ass sportsman. . . the SpearFisherman wins, hands down.

Need proof? Give it a try.
__________________
that's a good answer, and actually proves my point. A friend built his own spear gun, looks very fancy. I saw him free dive 28' of water and twice come up with big fish. Proof, give it a try? RIGHT,looks like its a challenge. You are constantly swimming, holding a 7-8 lb spear gun[maybe you can verify the weight of the gun], and you don't even think about how physical it all is, because, you like doing it.
A hunter walks out into the woods, carries a 12 lb rifle around all day, climbs a tree, climbs back down, drags a 150-200 lb deer out of the woods, and had a great day.
The fisherman looks at a fishing rod and says, it must be "lightweight and sensitive" I was never a math major, and I guess that's because I never understood why a fishing rod that weighed an additional 2 oz. makes any difference?:confused: I think the hunter wins.

[JBird]

I'd have to go with a spearfisherman but only free divers. If you have a tank then it's like being in a tree stand over a clover patch.

Also, the ocean can kick your ass better than the forest.